What if the best tool is the one you do not add?
Name the problem before comparing solutions, then consider adoption and maintenance costs beyond the initial installation.
Name the need before the solution
A successful demo often makes you want to try a new tool. Before adopting it, I suggest describing the work that causes problems today. Who encounters the difficulty? How often? Those answers let you evaluate proposed features against a project need.
For example, a team may struggle to find its decisions because notes are scattered. Before switching software, it can try gathering them in one place. If that is enough, the problem may not justify the cost of a new tool.
Look at what the team will have to maintain
Installation is a small part of adoption. Someone will need to understand configuration, share practices, handle updates and know what to do when the tool no longer meets the need. That work deserves comparison with the time you hope to save, alongside the people who will actually do it.
- Who will be able to explain and maintain the configuration?
- Which data or practices become dependent on the tool?
- How can existing work be recovered if you decide to switch?
- Which need can be addressed with tools already in use?
Try it on a limited case
For this team, a trial could cover decisions for a single project. Can the people involved find the latest decision and its justification without asking a colleague? Defining that question before the trial provides a criterion for evaluating the tool after discovering it.
It is also useful to define how the trial ends. What records should be retained? Who decides what happens next? How will data be reintegrated if you do not continue? Preparing this exit makes the experiment easier to limit and its result easier to discuss.
Choose what simplifies the actual work
The trial may also show that the tool addresses a constraint difficult to handle otherwise. If suitable search helps the team find its decisions, that gain deserves comparison with the maintenance and migration work assessed earlier.
At the end of the trial, record what led to the decision, including difficulties encountered. If the need changes, the team can revisit that decision with its context.