MIT or Apache 2.0: which licence should you choose for your project?
MIT or Apache 2.0: compare obligations, patents and reuse constraints to choose a licence that fits your project.
Publishing a library: which should you choose?
You are preparing to publish a library and deciding between MIT and Apache 2.0. You want to allow reuse, including in paid products whose source code stays private. Both licences meet that goal, provided their conditions are respected. The commercial nature of a future product is therefore insufficient to choose between them.
For code whose rights I control, I would choose MIT if the priority is a short text and few redistribution formalities. I would favour Apache 2.0 if the project wants to explicitly grant certain contributors’ patent rights and accepts more detailed notice obligations. These are decision criteria; constraints from the components used still need checking before choosing.
Compare the consequences for people reusing the code
A team reusing your code should be able to determine what it will pass on to its own users. Here are the differences between the standard texts, criterion by criterion:
- Commercial use and private code: MIT and Apache 2.0 allow sales and do not, on their own, require publication of a product’s source code or its modifications. Neither requires contributing changes back to the original project.
- Notices to pass on: MIT requires preservation of the copyright and permission notice in copies or substantial portions of the software. Apache 2.0 requires a copy of its licence for recipients and preservation of applicable notices in distributed derivative source code. In both cases, I would preserve the full text supplied with the component.
- Modified files: Apache 2.0 requires prominent notices in changed files. MIT does not state that particular obligation. Original notices must still be preserved according to the relevant licence.
- NOTICE file: if the original Apache 2.0 distribution includes one, relevant attributions must be reproduced in distributed derivative works, in an authorised location. Apache 2.0 does not require systematically creating this file. MIT has no equivalent specific mechanism.
- Patents: Apache 2.0 contains an explicit grant, limited to claims each contributor can license that are necessarily infringed by their contribution alone or with the relevant software. MIT has no equivalent explicit clause; this does not settle whether implied rights may exist.
- Warranty: both texts provide for supply as is and disclaim warranties and liability. Choosing Apache 2.0 does not make the project guaranteed against third-party claims.
The Apache patent clause also terminates patent licences granted for the software if you bring certain infringement actions targeting that software or an incorporated contribution. This mechanism concerns litigation defined by section 3. Read it alongside the scope of the grant, without inferring general protection against all patents.
Choose for your code, preserve your dependencies’ terms
The choice requires holding the necessary rights to the published code. Other people’s contributions, employer rules and files reused from an existing project may limit that choice. Replacing LICENSE at the root is not enough to acquire missing rights.
Take a fictional example: you publish your own tool under MIT and it includes an Apache 2.0 component. Your choice does not remove Apache 2.0 from that component. You must still respect its redistribution conditions, including handling NOTICE if one exists. Conversely, using MIT code in an Apache 2.0 project requires preserving the applicable MIT notices.
For an existing application, I would start by inventorying what is actually distributed and the licences of its exact versions. The main licence’s name is a starting point for this analysis, without describing every file in the project.
Situations that influence the decision
Imagine a small conversion tool for which you wrote all the code. You want an easy-to-read permission and have no specific requirement for an explicit patent grant. After checking the rights, MIT would be my first choice. This recommendation follows your priority of readability; the project’s size or language does not dictate the licence.
Another fictional example: several organisations contribute to a development kit and want reusers to have an explicit clause covering contributors’ patents. I would favour Apache 2.0, after checking the rights that permit those contributions. You then need to track modified files and attributions in distributions. The number of companies alone does not justify this choice.
If your goal is to require publication of redistributed modifications, neither licence provides that reciprocity. You should examine a copyleft licence whose conditions match the desired scope. Adding your own obligation to the MIT or Apache text would produce a modified licence, requiring a different analysis for users.
Put compatibility ahead of preference
Does your code need to become part of a work governed by another licence? The Apache FAQ confirms compatibility with GPL version 3, but not GPL version 2 only. Where Apache 2.0 code must be combined with a GPL-2.0-only work, that constraint takes precedence over your preference for the patent clause. Merely using components side by side and creating a derivative work also require distinguishing what is actually combined.
Check the exact licence versions and any choices they allow. A project labelled GPL-2.0-or-later requires a different reading from one limited to GPL-2.0-only. Choosing MIT at the root does not automatically resolve an incompatibility between components already included.
Keep a verifiable decision in the repository
Once the constraints have been checked, I would record a short justification: ‘MIT for a short text and limited redistribution conditions’ or ‘Apache 2.0 for its explicit patent grant’. That sentence must correspond to a real project goal.
- Include the complete standard text in LICENSE and correctly identify the rights holders in notices appropriate to the project.
- Align package metadata with the choice, using the MIT or Apache-2.0 identifier. Keep third-party components’ licences and attributions separately.
- Open the delivered archive and verify that the required notices reach the recipient. For Apache 2.0, also check changed files and attributions from the upstream NOTICE when one exists.
These guidelines help choose between the standard texts. If contribution rights or compatibility of a combination remain uncertain, that specific issue must be resolved before distribution.
Sources and useful links
- Open Source Initiative: standard MIT licence text
- Apache Software Foundation: Apache 2.0 conditions and patent clause
- Apache: FAQ on contributions, redistribution and GPL compatibility
- GitHub Choose a License: rights and obligations under MIT
- GitHub Choose a License: rights and obligations under Apache 2.0
- GitHub Open Source Guides: choose based on goals, dependencies and contributors’ rights
- Taking over a project: inventory dependencies before deciding